When evaluating the Braves’ needs approaching the trade deadline, the outfield stands out glaringly. Adam Duvall struggles against right-handed pitchers, and players like Forrest Wall, Ramon Laureano, and Brian Anderson are barely holding onto their MLB careers.
While Michael Harris II’s return promises a boost, Atlanta requires additional outfield depth — one starter and one insurance player — to safeguard against potential injuries.
Equally pressing is the shortstop position, which has emerged as a significant concern. Orlando Arcia, once touted as a starting-caliber player, has largely faltered offensively throughout his nine-year career. Despite a brief resurgence last season that earned him an All-Star nod, Arcia’s performance has sharply declined in 2024. Currently, he ranks as one of the least productive hitters in baseball, with an on-base percentage below .250 and a dismal batting average hovering near the Mendoza Line. Over the past two months, his offensive woes have deepened, posting a batting average of .166 and a wRC+ of 32, significantly below league average.
Arcia’s struggles extend beyond a mere slump; historically, he has not excelled offensively, a reality underscored by his underwhelming second half last year. Despite his reputation as a solid defensive shortstop earlier in the season, Arcia’s defensive prowess has also waned since April, now merely average.
The Braves’ recent call-up, Nacho Alvarez, has garnered attention with an impressive stint at Gwinnett, boasting a .358 batting average, nine extra-base hits, and an OPS above 1.000 in just 16 games. While Atlanta may be hesitant to rush the 21-year-old into a starting role after such a brief minor league stint, the urgency to address their shortstop dilemma is mounting.
Orlando Arcia on the season 5 OAA
By month:
March/April: 5 OAA
May: 2 OAA
June: -2 OAA— Trent (@Trenciarte) June 30, 2024
If not Alvarez, the Braves must explore trade options to secure a more reliable shortstop. Acquiring such a player ahead of the deadline poses a challenge, as shortstops are typically not readily available in trade talks. Nonetheless, potential targets from teams like the Blue Jays could offer substantial upgrades over Arcia and provide Atlanta with much-needed stability at the position.
