The Cincinnati Bengals are approaching the NFL trade deadline with the prospect of securing a playoff spot within their sights. As they prepare for the Nov. 5 deadline, they have three more games to assess their strategy—whether to acquire new talent, offload players, or maintain their current roster.
The Bengals have recently been on a positive trajectory, winning three of their last four games in an increasingly competitive AFC North. Given their relatively favorable schedule in the coming weeks, this could be an opportune time for them to enhance their chances of success. One suggested path for improvement involves pursuing a superstar edge rusher from a division rival likely to enter sell mode as the deadline approaches.
In a bold trade proposal put forth by Alex Kay of Bleacher Report, the Bengals would send five draft picks to the Cleveland Browns in exchange for star pass rusher Myles Garrett. The proposed deal includes two first-round picks (in 2025 and 2026), two third-round picks (also in 2025 and 2026), and a fourth-round pick in 2026.
Kay emphasizes that acquiring Garrett would significantly boost a Bengals defense that has struggled against high-caliber opponents this season. If the Bengals’ front office believes they can turn around their early-season struggles and make a playoff run by adding a key player, the steep price for Garrett—who is the reigning Defensive Player of the Year—might be justified. This acquisition could provide a game-changing element to Cincinnati’s defensive line, particularly alongside Trey Hendrickson, who has had an impressive start to the season.
However, executing an in-division trade is inherently complex, especially given the competitive nature of the AFC North. The Browns may find it challenging to rebuild effectively while dealing with the substantial salary-cap hit from quarterback Deshaun Watson’s contract. This financial constraint could play a significant role in their willingness to part ways with a premier player like Garrett.
Mortgaging the future by trading multiple draft picks is a considerable risk, but the Bengals face a pressing need to strengthen their roster. They also have future salary considerations, especially with star wide receiver Ja’Marr Chase in line for a significant contract extension soon. Despite these challenges, the Bengals’ window for making a deep playoff run remains open, particularly if they can land a player of Garrett’s caliber.
Ultimately, while the trade proposal is ambitious and fraught with potential pitfalls, it reflects the Bengals’ determination to capitalize on their recent successes and pursue a stronger position in the postseason. Whether they can finalize such a deal with the Browns remains to be seen, but it underscores the urgency for Cincinnati as they approach a pivotal moment in their season.
