As the New York Yankees continue to rebuild their roster following Juan Soto’s departure to the New York Mets, securing a first baseman has become a priority. With Cody Bellinger already added to bolster center field, the Yankees retain the flexibility to explore various solutions at first base, potentially utilizing Bellinger’s versatility if necessary. One name that has emerged as a potential target is Paul Goldschmidt, a former MVP who could bring invaluable leadership and experience to the team.
At 37 years old, Goldschmidt is coming off a disappointing 2024 season, having posted a slash line of .245/.302/.414 with 22 home runs, 65 RBIs, and a 100 wRC+, marking his first year as a league-average hitter. This decline follows a much stronger 2023 campaign where he hit .268 with 25 homers and 80 RBIs, and posted a 122 wRC+. Despite his drop in production, the veteran first baseman still boasts a significant pedigree, having been a dominant presence in 2022 when he slashed .317/.404/.578 with 35 home runs and 115 RBIs during his MVP-winning season.
While his offensive numbers have decreased, Goldschmidt’s defense at first base remains a reliable asset. In 2024, he played 1,313 innings with a .996 fielding percentage, committing only five errors over 150 games. Though his defensive metrics, such as zero defensive runs saved and zero outs above average, reflect an average performance, the Yankees might believe they can help him improve in the field. One of the main advantages of pursuing Goldschmidt is that he did not receive a qualifying offer this offseason, meaning the Yankees wouldn’t need to sacrifice a draft pick to sign him. This makes him a more attractive option compared to other targets like Christian Walker, whose acquisition would involve additional draft-related costs.
Goldschmidt’s likely price tag, considering his recent performance, would make him a cost-effective choice compared to other power-hitting first basemen available. With a distinguished career that includes five Silver Slugger Awards, four Gold Gloves, and seven All-Star selections, Goldschmidt remains a respected figure in the league, which could make him an intriguing short-term option for the Yankees.
Alternatively, the Yankees could consider other free-agent options, such as Carlos Santana, who might offer better value due to his lower cost and consistent defensive play. Santana, a switch-hitter, recently won a Gold Glove and offers flexibility and reliability at first base. However, if the Yankees believe that Goldschmidt can recapture some of his past form for one more impactful season, he could be worth the investment. His history of elite offensive performance, combined with his solid defensive track record, could provide a valuable boost to the Yankees’ lineup, without necessitating a long-term financial commitment. Ultimately, Goldschmidt could offer a bridge for the Yankees at first base while helping them remain competitive in the 2025 season.
